Progress
Which kata are we practising today
?
I already know this kata
!
I do not need this kata for my next
rank !
We already did this kata the last time
!
Are we going to do a new kata today
?
When will we learn the high katas
?
This kata is boring
!
Sometimes, instructors feel like
conducters facing an orchestra not mastering the musical
instruments. Hardly able to play simple melodies or just scales, the
musicians wish for rehearsing different compositions all
the time. A little bit of Beethoven, ten minutes Bruckner, twenty
minutes Mahler, loosened up with Sibelius, and for warming
up a touch of Bernstein.
At
tournaments one can watch student participants, even children,
performing kata intended for high Dan grades. This resembles someone
not being able to play the piano but nonetheless pleasing the
audience performing Rachmaninov by memorizing
the
sequence in which to push the many same-looking keys on the
instrument.
Progress means getting better. It is not the ability to
express some kind of superficiality in as much ways as
possible. For training, this entails to focus on frequent
repetitions of a limited number of exercises. Thus, one can obtain a
deeper principal understanding
This
establishes the basis for learning new things and for improving
the established ones. Somebody knowing ten katas superficially
will perform the eleventh one in a similiar mediocre
fashion because he is only able to transfer his inability. On
the other hand, somebody able to master only few or even only one
kata can apply his knowledge to many other
things.
The consumption of ever more and more exotic techniques,
forms, and exercises corresponds to a holiday camp
attitude. Apart from its entertainment value, it only
produces illusions of progress and high standards.
© 1999 TDI |